BrokerBay vs ShowingTime (2026): Which Is Right for Your Real Estate Business?

Published November 13, 2026 · Realty Software Editorial

When a buyer's agent calls to schedule a showing, the last thing a listing agent wants is a scheduling mess. Showing management software exists to eliminate that friction — but two platforms dominate most US markets: ShowingTime and BrokerBay. Both sit at the center of the scheduling workflow for hundreds of thousands of agents, yet they come from different ownership structures, serve different primary audiences, and make meaningfully different tradeoffs. This guide breaks down exactly where each platform wins, where it falls short, and which fits your situation in 2026.

Quick verdict

ShowingTime is the safe default for individual agents and small teams — it is already built into most US MLS memberships, free to start, and deeply integrated with the broader real estate software stack. BrokerBay is the stronger choice for brokerages, franchise networks, and associations that need enterprise-grade permissioning, dual-lockbox coverage, and showing analytics at scale. If your MLS offers both, the decision often comes down to whether you need brokerage-level controls or simply a reliable scheduling tool that works out of the box.

BrokerBay overview

BrokerBay, now operating as "Supra showing management, powered by BrokerBay," is owned by Honeywell's Supra division and built for structured, multi-tier real estate organizations. More than 140,000 agents access it through participating MLS boards at no additional cost, but the platform's real differentiators show up at the brokerage and franchise level. Its hierarchical permissioning system lets a franchise configure scheduling policies that cascade down to regional offices, then to individual teams — a capability ShowingTime has historically not matched at the same depth. BrokerBay also offers native integration with both Supra and SentriLock electronic lockboxes, covering the two dominant lockbox ecosystems without requiring any third-party bridge. Its brokerage analytics dashboard tracks showing volume, feedback rates, and listing performance down to the office and team level, making it a reporting tool as much as a scheduling tool. The platform added 3D virtual showing capabilities and an answering service to its feature set, signaling a push toward being a full showing ecosystem rather than just an appointment-scheduling layer.

ShowingTime overview

ShowingTime, acquired by Zillow in 2021, is the category default in US residential real estate. Agents in most US markets can access it through their MLS membership at no cost, making it the path of least resistance for agents who need reliable appointment scheduling without IT overhead. Its strength is breadth: near-universal adoption means counterpart agents almost always have an account, and its CRM and lockbox integrations cover the major platforms an agent is likely to use. Beyond basic scheduling, ShowingTime offers automated feedback request workflows, a Secure Access lockbox product, market insights for listing presentations, and offer management with side-by-side comparison tools. The platform has expanded into brokerage analytics through its MarketView Broker product, which tracks 17 agent performance metrics for recruiting and retention. Zillow's ownership has created friction with some brokerages that view Zillow as a competitor, but for agents who primarily care about scheduling efficiency, that ownership has little day-to-day operational impact.

Head-to-head

Feature BrokerBay ShowingTime
Agent pricing Free via participating MLS Free via MLS (most US markets)
Direct brokerage pricing $8/active listing/mo (custom for large networks) Custom pricing; contact sales
Contract terms Custom; demo required Custom; pricing not published
Appointment scheduling Web, mobile app, answering service Web, mobile app, 24/7 appointment center
Lockbox integration Native Supra + SentriLock (both ecosystems) Multiple systems via Secure Access product
Brokerage analytics Built-in (franchise → office → team hierarchy) MarketView Broker (separate product tier)
Offer management Not included in showing workflow Yes — side-by-side offer comparison
Feedback collection Yes (text only; no photo attachments) Yes (automated requests)
Market insights Analytics dashboard (brokerage-level) Yes — MarketView, shareable client reports
Mobile app Yes Yes
Ownership Honeywell / Supra Systems Zillow

Pros and cons

BrokerBay

  • Pro: Native dual-lockbox integration covers both Supra and SentriLock without third-party bridges, eliminating a common compatibility headache for multi-brand brokerages.
  • Pro: Hierarchical permissioning — franchise → regional → brokerage → office → team → agent — is purpose-built for complex organizations and exceeds what most competitors offer for enterprise control.
  • Pro: Included in core MLS service at participating boards, so agents in partner markets pay nothing extra for base scheduling features.
  • Pro: Brokerage analytics dashboard tracks showing volume and listing performance at the team level, turning scheduling data into management intelligence without a separate analytics subscription.
  • Con: Availability is entirely dependent on MLS or brokerage participation — agents outside partner markets have no self-serve path to adoption, which limits its reach significantly compared to ShowingTime's near-universal US presence.
  • Con: Direct brokerage pricing at $8 per active listing per month scales steeply for high-inventory offices not covered by an MLS-sponsored plan. A brokerage managing 300 active listings could face over $2,400 per month in showing software costs alone.
  • Con: Offer management is not built into the showing workflow. Agents must context-switch to a separate tool to manage and compare offers, introducing friction at the most critical stage of the transaction.
  • Con: Feedback submissions cannot include photos, leaving a gap when buyers or their agents need to document property conditions observed during the showing — a limitation that matters most for high-end or condition-sensitive listings.

ShowingTime

  • Pro: Near-universal US market adoption means listing agents rarely encounter counterpart agents without an account, reducing scheduling friction to near zero in established markets.
  • Pro: Offer management with side-by-side comparison is built into the platform, covering more of the transaction lifecycle than a pure scheduling tool and reducing the need for a separate offer platform.
  • Pro: Broad CRM and lockbox integrations cover most major real estate platforms an agent is likely to use, with minimal configuration required after initial MLS setup.
  • Pro: Automated feedback request workflow collects responses from buyer's agents without listing agent follow-up, keeping feedback rates high with minimal effort.
  • Con: Zillow's ownership is a genuine strategic risk for brokerages that compete with Zillow's buyer-side services. Some brokerages have adopted BrokerBay specifically to reduce data dependency on a direct competitor — this concern is real and not merely hypothetical.
  • Con: The base free tier is limited; brokerage-level analytics, team management features, and advanced front-desk tools require paid plan upgrades with pricing that is not publicly listed and requires a sales contact to obtain.
  • Con: Customization options are limited compared to BrokerBay — brokerages cannot configure hierarchical permissioning policies that cascade across franchise structures, which matters for multi-office operations that need standardized scheduling rules.
  • Con: ShowingTime's appointment center, while reliable, operates as a third-party call center. Brokerages have limited control over the scheduling experience and the data generated by that center, which can be a concern for brokerages that want to own their own client interaction data.

Which should you choose?

Solo agents and small teams: ShowingTime is almost always the right answer. If your MLS already includes it, there is no setup cost, no adoption friction with counterpart agents, and the core feature set covers everything a solo agent needs: appointment scheduling, automated feedback, market insights for listing presentations, and built-in offer management. Unless your MLS has switched to BrokerBay, there is no practical reason to change platforms.

Growing teams with admin staff: ShowingTime's Front Desk tier adds team branding, team leader visibility into all showings, and customizable feedback workflows that suit a licensed admin managing a lead agent's calendar. BrokerBay becomes more attractive if you are part of a brokerage that has already adopted it, since team-level analytics are built into the core platform rather than requiring an additional product tier.

Independent brokerages and regional networks: BrokerBay's enterprise permissioning and dual lockbox coverage make it the stronger choice for brokerages that want to standardize showing management across offices. The $8 per active listing direct pricing creates real cost at scale, so the economics work best under MLS sponsorship. ShowingTime's MarketView Broker is a compelling alternative if you are already in the ShowingTime ecosystem, but the Zillow ownership question deserves a deliberate board-level decision rather than a default.

Franchise networks and MLS administrators: BrokerBay is the clearer winner. Its hierarchical role system, board-wide ecosystem model, and native integration with both major lockbox ecosystems make it purpose-built for the administrative complexity of multi-tier franchise organizations and MLS deployments.

See the full side-by-side feature breakdown at BrokerBay vs ShowingTime for a live comparison updated from both platform listings.

Ready to go deeper? Explore the full BrokerBay listing and the ShowingTime listing on Realty Software for detailed reviews, feature checklists, and links to free demos for both platforms.

Keep reading

Ready for matching recommendations?

Answer three quick questions and we'll point you at the right software for your business.

Get my top 3 matches